Plastic, Concrete, or Steel Bollards: Which is Best for Commercial Properties?
Choosing the right bollard material for your commercial property can significantly impact both your upfront investment and long-term operational costs. With plastic, concrete, and steel each offering distinct advantages, deciding which to use depends on the function it needs to serve and in what context. Let’s examine each material to help you make the best decision for your business.
Steel Bollards: The Commercial Standard
Steel remains the most popular choice for commercial applications, offering superior strength and professional appearance. However, steel is prone to corrosion, discolouration and rust over time, so steel bollards typically feature a stainless or galvanised coating to prevent this.
Advantages:
- Maximum impact resistance for high-security applications
- Professional appearance suitable for corporate environments
- Can be powder-coated in various colors to match branding
- Proven track record in commercial settings
Disadvantages:
- Requires regular maintenance to prevent rust and corrosion
- Higher upfront costs compared to other materials
- Normal, annual maintenance costs can add up significantly over time
Concrete Bollards: Low-Maintenance Durability
Concrete bollards typically feature high-pressure cement for increased durability and security. They are easy to paint and maintain and provide a clean finish for a sophisticated look. Concrete bollards, of course, are not affected by chemical changes that impact metals.
Advantages:
- Excellent weather resistance in Canadian climates
- No risk of rust or corrosion
- Cost-effective for large installations
- Minimal maintenance, making them ideal for those seeking a hardier alternative
Disadvantages:
- Heavier weight can complicate installation
- Should not generally be used for higher security applications
- Limited aesthetic options compared to steel
Plastic/Polymer Bollards: Flexible and Maintenance-Free
Polymer bollards are a more lightweight and flexible alternative to the solid structures of steel and concrete bollards. The polymer plastic material offers a flexibility that isn’t possible with steel or concrete, this allows the bollard to bend on impact and return to its original shape.
Advantages:
- The HDPE cover requires no maintenance and will look brand new for years
- Lightweight and easy to install
- Self-restoring flexibility reduces damage from minor impacts
- Available in bright colors for high visibility
Disadvantages:
- Limited impact resistance for high-security applications
- May not provide the professional appearance required for some commercial settings
- Can become brittle in extreme cold weather
Cost Considerations: Beyond Initial Purchase
When evaluating bollard materials, consider the total cost of ownership over time. Low-maintenance options can provide significant savings when factoring in ongoing maintenance requirements, repainting, and potential replacement costs.
Installation costs typically range between $500-$1,200 per bollard, depending on the size of the bollards, the amount of bollards, and the installation process, making material choice crucial for budget planning.
The Verdict for Commercial Applications
For most GTA commercial properties, steel bollards remain the optimal choice when properly maintained. They offer the best combination of security, professional appearance, and long-term durability. However, for budget-conscious projects or applications where maintenance access is limited, concrete bollards provide excellent value.
The right bollard choice will provide the ideal balance of aesthetics, durability, strength, functionality and value for your unique setting and risk factors. Consider your specific security needs, aesthetic requirements, and maintenance capabilities when making your decision.
Ready to choose the perfect bollard material for your commercial property? Contact Bollard Boys GTA today for expert guidance and professional installation. Our team serves Toronto and the GTA with high-quality bollard solutions tailored to your specific needs and budget.